AtoZRanking

AirTags vs Tile: Which Tracker Should You Buy?

9/22/2025 · Trackers · 6 min

AirTags vs Tile: Which Tracker Should You Buy?

TL;DR

  • AirTags deliver the best precision and network reach for iPhone users thanks to Ultra Wideband and the Find My network. Great for keys and luggage if you use Apple devices.
  • Tile works across iOS and Android and offers a wider model range, including very small trackers and Bluetooth-only options. Better choice for mixed-device households.
  • Best picks by use case:
  • Apple-only users who need pin-point accuracy: AirTag.
  • Android or mixed households: Tile Mate or Tile Pro for compatibility.
  • Budget or replaceable battery needs: Tile Mate or Tile Sticker.
  • Luggage and long-range recovery: AirTag or Tile Pro with premium subscription for network features.

How these trackers work

  • Both use Bluetooth Low Energy for local detection and rely on large networks of devices to report lost items.
  • AirTag adds Ultra Wideband (UWB) for precise, directional finding with supported iPhone models.
  • Tile focuses on broad platform compatibility and sells multiple models with different sizes and adhesives.

Range and Accuracy

  • Bluetooth range is typically 15 to 60 meters in open space, but walls reduce that. Practical detection is usually within 10 meters indoors.
  • AirTag + UWB provides meter-level directional guidance on recent iPhones, which is noticeably more accurate when nearby.
  • Tile Pro has stronger Bluetooth radios than Tile Mate, which can extend effective range a bit for searching nearby items.

Battery and Maintenance

  • AirTag: user-replaceable CR2032 battery rated for around 1 year. No subscription required for basic features.
  • Tile: varies by model. Some use replaceable batteries (Tile Pro), others have sealed batteries rated 3 years (Tile Sticker). Tile offers a subscription for extended services like Smart Alerts and longer location history.
  • Replaceable batteries are convenient for long term ownership; sealed models are lighter but need full replacement when dead.

Ecosystem and Device Compatibility

  • AirTag is deeply integrated with Apple Find My and works best when you own an iPhone, iPad, or Mac. Android support is minimal and limited to NFC lost mode scans.
  • Tile apps are available on both iOS and Android. Tile integrates with some third party platforms and voice assistants, making it a better cross-platform choice.

Network Size and Lost Item Recovery

  • A larger user network means better chances of finding lost items. Apple benefits from a massive Find My network across many devices.
  • Tile has a sizable user base and lifetime of active devices, but its density depends on your local area. Premium Tile subscriptions can improve recovery options and location history.

Privacy and Security

  • Both systems use anonymized, encrypted handoffs so location reporting is private.
  • Anti-stalking features: both platforms implement alerts when an unknown tracker is moving with you, but implementation and timing differ. iPhone users get tighter integration and faster alerts for AirTags.

App Experience and Extras

  • AirTag: simple setup and tight OS integration, minimal app clutter since it lives in Find My. No cross-platform app.
  • Tile: feature rich app with community find, sharing, separation alerts with subscription, and accessories. Easier to manage across devices from different manufacturers.

Which Should You Buy?

  • Choose AirTag if: you are primarily in the Apple ecosystem, want the most precise close-range finding, and prefer a set-and-forget experience without subscriptions.
  • Choose Tile if: you need Android compatibility, want a wider variety of form factors, or need adhesive options and cross-platform sharing.

Buying Checklist

-

  • Ecosystem: Apple only = AirTag. Mixed or Android = Tile.
  • Form factor: need adhesive or tiny trackers = Tile Sticker or Tile Slim.
  • Accuracy: need directional, meter-level finding = AirTag with UWB iPhone.
  • Battery preference: replaceable battery = AirTag or Tile Pro. Sealed battery = Tile Sticker.
  • Subscription needs: Tile premium adds features; AirTag offers core features without subscription.

Bottom Line

AirTags are the best choice for iPhone users who want seamless precision and vast passive network coverage. Tile is the better pick for cross-platform households, a wider selection of tracker styles, and users who value Android support. Pick based on the devices you own and the form factor you need.

Found this helpful? Check our curated picks on the home page.